What a disqualifying event is
HMRC's manual ETASSUM57050 says a number of changes can disqualify an option from EMI relief. These are called disqualifying events. A disqualifying event restricts tax relief. If the option is exercised within 90 days of the event (40 days for events before 17 July 2013), the tax advantages are preserved. If it is not exercised within that window, there will be a tax charge on exercise.
The law is in Part 7, Chapter 9 of ITEPA 2003 (sections 533 to 539). Whether a particular fact pattern is a disqualifying event is a tax question for you or your adviser. This page restates what HMRC publishes and how the annual return records it.
The eight numbers on the EMI return
HMRC's EMI technical note lists the disqualifying event numbers you enter when the answer to "Is this the result of a disqualifying event?" is yes:
- Company has come under control of another company.
- Company has ceased to meet the trading activities requirements.
- The option holder has ceased to meet the working time requirement.
- Terms of option varied causing value of shares to be increased or option no longer a qualifying option.
- Variation of share capital which results in disqualifying event.
- Shares were converted into a different class of shares and this conversion did not happen to the whole class of shares.
- The option holder has been granted an option under a CSOP resulting in them holding EMI and CSOP options over shares with a UMV in excess of the maximum entitlement.
- The company has not started to carry on a qualifying trade within two years of the grant of the option, or preparations to carry on a qualifying trade have ceased.
See also follow-on questions for when the number is mandatory on the template.
Company level events
ETASSUM57080 covers loss of independence and loss of the trading activities requirement. Loss of independence is a disqualifying event except where a qualifying replacement option is granted under the EMI rules. If the company was preparing to trade when the option was granted, there is a disqualifying event if preparations stop, or if a qualifying trade has not begun within two years of grant.
On the annual return
Disqualifying events that lead to a release, lapse, cancellation or a taxable exercise are reported on the relevant EMI sheet for the tax year. New grants are notified separately, not on the annual return. See which EMI sheet each event goes on and how to file the EMI return.
Share Scheme Return checks that a "yes" to a disqualifying event has a number from 1 to 8. It does not decide whether an event is disqualifying.
Questions
How long do I have to exercise after a disqualifying event?
HMRC's ETASSUM57050 says tax advantages are preserved if the option is exercised within 90 days of the event (40 days for older events before 17 July 2013).
Where do I put the event number?
On HMRC's EMI template, when "Is this the result of a disqualifying event?" is yes, enter the number from 1 to 8 listed in the technical note.
Is becoming a subsidiary always fatal?
Loss of independence is a disqualifying event, but ETASSUM57080 says it is not one for the old option where a qualifying replacement option is granted under the EMI rules.
Can the checker tell me if an event is disqualifying?
No. That is a tax question for you or your adviser. The checker only checks that the answers on the file are complete and consistent.
Based on HMRC's published guidance: ETASSUM57050 tax consequences after a disqualifying event. ETASSUM57080 company level events. ITEPA 2003 Part 7 Chapter 9. EMI technical note. Checked on 5 November 2026. This is general guidance, not tax advice, and HMRC's own pages take priority if they change. Share Scheme Return is not affiliated with HMRC.
Let the free checker find these for you
Load your option register or finished return and see every row that breaks HMRC's published rules, with the reason and the fix. Nothing is uploaded, and you don't need an account.