Check your file freeCheck free

EMI valuation: VAL231, AMV, UMV and the annual return

How HMRC's Shares and Assets Valuation agrees an EMI share value on form VAL231, what AMV and UMV mean, how long agreement lasts, and what goes on the annual return.

Do you need an HMRC valuation?

HMRC's EMI guidance notes say it is not necessary to have formally agreed the valuation of shares with HMRC. If you did agree a valuation, put the reference on the return. If you did not, keep records of how you reasonably established the value. See follow-on questions for how the return asks about this.

If you want HMRC to agree values before you grant options, use form VAL231 and the steps on Get a share scheme valuation from HMRC.

What VAL231 asks for

GOV.UK says you fill in VAL231 to get an EMI valuation, and you need to propose the unrestricted market value and actual market value for any shares under options that carry restrictions which affect their market value.

  • Actual market value (AMV): the value after taking into account any restrictions or risk of forfeiture (EMI guidance notes, section 1.2).
  • Unrestricted market value (UMV): the value ignoring any restrictions or risk of forfeiture (section 1.3).

HMRC's Shares and Assets Valuation manual (SVM110050) says SAV will consider a valuation of both AMV and UMV submitted with VAL231, and that applicants should not approach SAV until the company is in a position to grant the EMI options. Agreement of EMI valuations is a voluntary service: you may grant options without the value being agreed.

How long an agreed EMI valuation lasts

Get a share scheme valuation from HMRC says valuations for EMIs are valid for 90 days from the date of the agreement. SVM110050 adds that this is subject to there being no changes in the company's circumstances that might affect the value of its shares before the options are issued. If options are not granted in time, you submit a fresh VAL231.

What goes on the EMI annual return

On HMRC's template, values are in pounds and pence to 4 decimal places. Where shares are not listed on a recognised stock exchange and you answered that the market value was agreed with HMRC, enter the valuation reference without any CRN letters. See how to complete the EMI annual return and decimal places.

Share Scheme Return checks that follow-on valuation answers are complete and consistent. It does not value your shares or replace advice from your adviser or from HMRC's SAV team.

Questions

Is an HMRC EMI valuation compulsory?

No. HMRC's EMI guidance notes say it is not necessary to have formally agreed the valuation with HMRC. Agreeing one through VAL231 is voluntary.

How long does an agreed EMI valuation last?

GOV.UK says EMI valuations are valid for 90 days from the date of agreement, provided company circumstances have not changed before grant.

What is AMV versus UMV?

AMV takes restrictions or forfeiture risk into account. UMV ignores them. Both are defined in HMRC's EMI guidance notes.

What do I put on the annual return?

If a valuation was agreed, enter the HMRC reference without any CRN prefix. Values go to 4 decimal places.

Based on HMRC's published guidance: Get a share scheme valuation from HMRC. VAL231 form. SVM110050 EMI valuations. EMI guidance notes. Checked on 5 November 2026. This is general guidance, not tax advice, and HMRC's own pages take priority if they change. Share Scheme Return is not affiliated with HMRC.

Let the free checker find these for you

Load your option register or finished return and see every row that breaks HMRC's published rules, with the reason and the fix. Nothing is uploaded, and you don't need an account.

Check your file free See pricing